Best Oysters in Brooklyn

If you’re in the mood for some delicious oysters and are around the Brooklyn area, then you are spoilt for choice. These mouth-watering mollusks are a favorite on numerous menus across the East Coast.

With so many restaurants offering their share of oysters, you may spend hours on end trying to decide where to go. That is why we have narrowed down the field for you. We have picked the best places for you to enjoy these seafood delectables.

New York is no stranger to oysters. A true institution, the Oyster Bar was one of the first eating establishments in the city.

It was also one of the first street foods as well. Brooklyn’s shores were so abundant with oysters that they were once sold at all-you-can-eat prices. Imagine that!

Over the years, things have changed. Freshly shuckled half-shells are now much pricier and are typically left for the more sophisticated establishments.

However, neo-oyster bars have started to rise again in recent years throughout Brooklyn. With too many to count, here are some of our favorite places to enjoy oysters in Brooklyn.

1. Marlow & Sons

81 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11249

If you want to experience the pre-industrial world of Brooklyn’s oyster bars, then check out Marlow & Sons. You really feel like you’re stepping back in time to the golden age of the oyster bars.

Marlow & Sons focus on fresh, East Coast oysters from Virginia’s Sting Rays to Rhode Island’s Rome Points. These come in several varieties to leave you in a pickle on what to choose. We recommend trying them all!

The atmosphere is inviting and cozy with an impressive selection of wines, beers, American artisanal cheeses, and special seasonal dishes. Go back every day to experience something new!

2. Maison Premiere

298 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn, New York 11249

If you’re crazy about oysters, then you will be even crazier for Maison Premiere. Rooted in the tradition and ceremonies of oyster bars, you will be catered for in style. The staff are happy to advise about shellfish so you can choose something to your taste.

Maison premiere specializes in oysters so you will not be disappointed here. There is an endless selection of oysters to choose from. And don’t forget to try their impressive choice of spirits, absinthes, and chilled crustaceans.

The decor is classy and dated to a by-gone era. Not only will you enjoy the wide range of oysters here but you will have a great time enjoying the lively atmosphere.

3. Walter Foods

166 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217

In the mood for a touch of class with your oysters? Why not try Walter Foods? This elegant establishment started as one of the highlights of Williamsburg’s Grand Street before hitting the dizzying heights of New York.

With the freshest oysters imaginable, you will be in awe of the sheer variety Walter Foods has to offer. Also available are raw seafood platters and the Chef’s special selections.

With a long, rich history already behind Walter Foods, you could become part of that history by dining on some delicious oysters in this friendly restaurant.

4. Prime Meats | OpenTable

465 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

For those of you who love to experience history, Prime Meats is the place for you. This farm-to-table restaurant has the spirit of the different inns and dining spaces of New York in the first part of the twentieth century.

Influenced by German cuisine, this exquisite restaurant’s appeal is only matched by its equally luscious oysters.

Arranged on an ice bed, these oysters are meticulously combined with a delicious cocktail sauce, that isn’t too sweet like so many are, a splash of freshly grated horseradish, fresh lemon, and mignonette.

All ingredients are fresh and local before being prepared honestly and simply. There is no messing about here. You want good oysters, you will get good oysters.

5. Littleneck

465 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

For a laid-back, seafood restaurant experience, there’s no better place than Littleneck. This Gowanus seafood shack is best known as a restaurant that got started from funds by a Kickstarter campaign.

Once Littleneck took off, there was no stopping this cozy restaurant. As well as offering excellent lobster and other seafood meals, there is a very generous offering of oyster varieties.

You can choose from both East Coast and West Coast oysters that are fresh every day.

As the name may suggest, Littleneck clams are also served on the half shell each and every day.

Customers regularly fall in love with the industrial nautical design of Littleneck. There is no doubt, once you step inside here, you will instantly feel at home.

How To Freeze Oysters

6. Sidecar

560 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Serving delicious cocktails and all-American comfort food, there isn’t much more you could ask for. Oysters, you say? That’s covered too!

You can choose from fried or fresh oysters every day at Sidecar. With a retro-based setting, this restaurant has an eclectic yet classically-filled menu to cater to all tastes.

Snack on your oysters with their famous house-made infusions and enjoy the classic, old-Brooklyn charm Sidecar has to offer.

We can’t go on without mentioning the friendly and knowledgeable staff too. They are always more than happy to help you decide what oysters are best and, of course, which cocktails they recommend.

7. Henry Public

329 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Henry Public is an old-time Brooklyn saloon with a unique and classic charm that is hard to find in modern times. Handsome is the best way to describe this restaurant.

As they say themselves, the “tavern honors the history and progressive spirit of our corner of Kings County.” And we can’t argue with that.

This tavern has a simple menu of hamburger sandwiches and bar snacks. Also available are oysters in the half shell. All of these together make Henry Public a timeless hit with customers.

If you’re looking for the barest essentials, then Henry Public is the place to go.

Don’t expect many vegetable dishes though. This is a traditional-like saloon with good, hearty food. You may feel like wearing a top hat just to fit in with the atmosphere!

8. Five Leaves

18 Bedford Ave., Greenpoint, BK, 11222

If you find yourself in the Greenpoint area, Five Leaves is one of, if not, the best neighborhood restaurants with reasonably-priced foods and drinks.

And don’t forget the scrumptious oysters on the varied menu! These are served on the half shell with a piquant rice wine mignonette. You can also choose flash-fried oysters with smoky aioli and cucumber relish. (Anyone else hungry yet?)

Although renowned for its luscious oysters, Five Leaves may be better known for its distinct antiquated nautical theme.

This is the place to eat oysters if you have ever wondered what it’s like to be a sailor fresh off the ship in need of some excellent food. Haven’t we all dreamed of this? Moving on!

9. OTB

141 Broadway, Williamsburg, NY 11211

Seafood has never tasted so good! OTB is a unique seafood eatery that is heaven for those of you who love to try new seafood dishes regularly. Oh, and the best wings in town!

This charming bistro and cocktail bar in Williamsburg, Brooklyn is the perfect place to spend Saturdays and Sundays having brunch with your friends.

With a wonderful selection of high-quality craft cocktails, you can sit back and enjoy the relaxing environment.

Oysters are, of course, a popular choice with the OTB menu. Currently $3, you can enjoy oysters with shallot mignonette and a very pleasant cocktail sauce. The perfect start, and end, to the weekend.

10. Bar Crudo

412 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Beginning life as a pop-up food place, Bar Crudo has evolved into one of Brooklyn’s hottest and most popular oyster bars and restaurants.

This establishment is committed to sourcing organic and sustainable local products whenever possible. This includes Bar Crudo’s own line of oysters.

These are cultivated by Salt Meadow Oyster Farm which is a small, family-owned farm located not far from New York City.

Not only do you get to enjoy some of the best oysters Brooklyn has to offer, but you get to support a local family-run business.

Also serving liquor, this is a great place to spend a relaxing evening with friends or call in for a tasty spot of lunch.

The only problem is, if you “pop-in”, you may not leave for a few hours due to the extensive supply of oysters and other food items. But hey, treat yourself! You deserve it.

Brooklyn Oysters

You are truly spoiled for choice in Brooklyn for oysters. Whether you’re living or just visiting Brooklyn, your day will not be complete without the taste of local oysters.

And with so many of these oyster bars recreating the golden age of oyster establishments of the early twentieth century, you will get to experience something new and exciting.

As we said, you deserve a treat. Go and enjoy Brooklyn’s finest oysters!