How To Eat Canned Oysters

Disclosure: Thank you for reading our articles! Some links may be affiliate links. We may get paid if you buy something or take an action after clicking one of these links.  Additionally, as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Canned oysters should be enjoyed in almost as many ways as fresh oysters, and have the benefit of being easy to purchase year round. These are a delightful treat that can be boiled, baked, fried, or eaten straight from the can.

Perhaps the easiest way to enjoy canned oysters is to fry them with oil and a sprinkling of herbs. Serve this on a cracker or some bruschetta, for a quick snack of a light lunch.

How To Eat Canned Oysters

Otherwise, try mixing them into pasta. Oysters taste fantastic with creamy sauces. If you have canned smoked oysters, sauté them with garlic, squeeze over lemon juice, and finish with a handful of Parmesan cheese.

Serve with angel hair pasta for a surprisingly fancy meal that comes together in no time at all.

Stews and casseroles can also be improved with the addition of canned oysters. Oysters have a meatiness that complements other seafood when used in a gumbo, and even works alongside heavier beef stews. 

For a classic dish, make canned oyster stuffing. Using stale bread and a variety of herbs, canned oyster stuffing is a decadent side dish for turkey or chicken.

Canned oysters can be eaten on pizzas, chopped into cream cheese, or folded into an omelette. Once you’ve fallen in love, you’ll try putting them in everything.

How long do canned oysters last?

Canned oysters are great store cupboard food because they can last in storage for at least 1 year. Some canned oysters may even be edible after 3 to 5 years, provided they’re properly stored. Always check the date on the can to be sure.

Once a can of oysters has been opened, they should be eaten as soon as possible. If you have an unused portion, keep these refrigerated and eat within 2 days. Don’t refrigerate them in the can, as the metal can degrade and affect the taste of the oysters.

Instead, decant any leftover oysters into a glass or plastic storage container. This will keep them tasting better. Cover the containers with a lid to prolong life, and keep the oysters away from other foods.

Many people associate oysters with luxury. By keeping canned oysters in your store cupboard you can impress guests year round, with none of the hassle of sourcing and shucking fresh oysters.

Canned oysters are an easy addition to pastas, stews, and soups, that add something special without costing a fortune.

Canned oysters should last for 1 year, but you may find they’re eaten well before that.

How long do canned smoked oysters last?

Canned smoked oysters taste like a delicacy but are actually a store cupboard essential. Stored properly, canned smoked oysters should be good for at least 1 year, but may remain tasty for up to 5 years. Check the can for an accurate use by date, and don’t eat any oysters past expiration.

Smoked oysters from an open can should be transferred into a glass or plastic container and kept in the refrigerator. These should be eaten within 2 days. 

To prolong the life of canned smoked oysters, they can be frozen. This should be done immediately after opening the can. Seal the oysters tightly in a freezer bag or in a covered airtight container.

In the freezer, smoked oysters will remain at their best for roughly three months. While they may still be good to eat for a while, their flavor and texture will begin to suffer. Defrost the oysters slowly in the refrigerator. Once defrosted, they should be cooked and eaten immediately.

Although freezing canned oysters is a good way to prolong their life, it does affect the texture. Defrosted oysters will be softer than those straight out of the can. This makes them better for stews and sauces.

How to tell if canned oysters are bad?

A pungent smell is the clearest way to tell if canned oysters have gone bad. If the oysters smell ‘off’ when you open the can, they should be discarded.

There may also be a change in appearance, such as a change in color. This will likely accompany the bad smell. Look for any signs of mold, which are a clear indicator that the oysters have gone bad. 

If you suspect your canned oysters have gone bad, then they should be thrown away immediately. Eaten expired oysters can cause serious sickness. 

It’s generally not possible to tell if canned oysters have gone bad until the can has been opened. Keep an eye on the use by date to be sure your canned oysters are still good to eat.

However, you may be able to tell from looking at the can if the oysters have gone bad. You should never eat food from damaged cans. If your can has started rusting, leaking, bulging, or is heavily dented, it should be discarded.

Odor and appearance are both indicators of bad canned oysters. This is accurate for both smoked and non-smoked canned oysters.

How to store canned oysters?

Unopened canned oysters should be stored in a cool, dry place. This should keep them at their best quality for up to a year.

Once they’ve been opened, any leftover portions should be refrigerated in a sealed glass or plastic container, and eaten within 2 days. Canned oysters may also be frozen after opening, which will keep them tasty for 3 months. Once defrosted, the texture will be softer.

Canned oysters are incredibly versatile, so keeping a pack in your cupboard is a fantastic idea.

If it’s your first time eating oysters, the long date means you have plenty of time to decide what to do with them. Try eating them straight from the can with a dash of hot sauce to really excite the taste buds.

Canned food sometimes has a reputation for being dull, but this isn’t true. Canned oysters are incredibly flavorful, and have the benefit of easy access and preparation. Keeping a tin alongside the beans and tomatoes allows you to add some richness to an otherwise bland dish.

How healthy are canned smoked oysters?

Canned smoked oysters are rich in antioxidants and B-12 vitamins, making them a surprisingly healthy food source. Canned oysters have similar health benefits to fresh oysters, but they are slightly higher in calories. 

There are numerous health benefits to canned smoked oysters. They contain all 9 essential amino acids alongside omega-3 fatty acids.

They’re also a rich source of proteins and minerals. Regularly eating canned oysters can boost your immune system, support muscle growth, and even strengthen your hair and nails.

However, canned smoked oysters are high in sodium, as this is used in the canning process. So while canned smoked oysters are a healthy seafood, they still shouldn’t be consumed daily. Avoid adding salt to canned smoked oysters. It shouldn’t be necessary for flavor anyway.

For the health conscious, be sure to check what the oysters are preserved in. The healthiest options are packed in water, rather than oil. Unfortunately, most smoked canned oysters are kept in oil. 

The prevalence of proteins and antioxidants in canned smoked oysters make them a healthy addition to a meal. Eating them regularly offers strength and support to the body. However, daily consumption isn’t recommended, due to the high sodium content.